| Question |
Sheets |
Flowers |
Boyer |
Carlson |
Kessenich |
| Division Finish |
1st |
1st |
1st |
3rd |
2nd |
| Mixed league sleeper (non-rookie) |
N Johnson |
Gardner |
N. Johnson |
N. Johnson |
Hughes |
| AL-only sleeper |
Aceves |
Aceves |
Aceves |
Chamberlain |
N. Johnson |
| Bust |
Vazquez |
N. Johnson |
Vazquez |
Pettitte |
Swisher |
| Top Rookie |
Montero |
Melancon |
Hoffmann |
Hoffmann |
Montero |
| Opening day starter in LF |
Damon |
Gardner |
Damon |
Granderson |
Not on roster |
| Vazquez's ERA- over/under 3.75 |
Over |
Over |
Over |
Over |
Under |
| A-Rod's HRs- over/under 40 |
Over |
Under |
Over |
Under |
Under |
| Granderson's HRs- over/under 25 |
Over |
Over |
Over |
Over |
Under |
| Back-to-back WS wins- yes or no |
No |
No |
Yes |
No |
No |
| Question |
Trachtman |
Wiegert |
K. Elfrink |
C. Elfrink |
Collette |
| Division Finish |
1st |
1st |
1st |
1st |
2nd |
| Mixed league sleeper (non-rookie) |
Aceves |
Cano |
N. Johnson |
Swisher |
Gardner |
| AL-only sleeper |
Marte |
Gardner |
Gardner |
Chamberlain |
Robertson |
| Bust |
Posada |
Vazquez |
Jeter |
N. Johnson |
N. Johnson |
| Top Rookie |
Hoffmann |
Cervelli |
Montero |
Montero |
Hoffmann |
| Opening day starter in LF |
Damon |
Gardner |
Gardner |
Gardner |
Gardner |
| Vazquez's ERA- over/under 3.75 |
Over |
Over |
Over |
Over |
Over |
| A-Rod's HRs- over/under 40 |
Over |
Over |
Under |
Over |
Under |
| Granderson's HRs- over/under 25 |
Over |
Over |
Over |
Over |
Over |
| Back-to-back WS wins- yes or no |
Yes |
No |
No |
Yes |
No |
CONSENSUS PICKS
Division finish: 1st
Mixed league sleeper (non-rookie): Nick Johnson
AL-only sleeper: Alfredo Aceves
Bust: Javier Vazquez
Top rookie: Jamie Hoffmann
Opening day starter in left field: Brett Gardner
Vazquez's ERA- over/under 3.75: Over
A-Rod's HRs- over/under 40: No consensus (five unders, five overs)
Granderson's HRs- over/under 25: Over
Back-to-back World Series wins: No
Click the links below to check out our polls for other teams:
AL East
Baltimore Orioles
Boston Red Sox